New · always available
Red Velvet Oreo Cream Cheese
A rich and soft red velvet cookie loaded with crushed Oreo pieces and white chocolate, stuffed with a smooth and creamy cream cheese filling.
Specialty $25 / 12pc · $45 / 24pc
The classics
Classic Box
Any mix of Biscoff, Mini Eggs, Matcha White Chocolate and Chocolate Chunk with Sea Salt.
12 pieces$20
24 pieces$35
With a specialty
Specialty Box
Everything in the classic box, plus Red Velvet Oreo Cream Cheese — the stuffed one.
12 pieces$25
24 pieces$45
Good to know
How the box works
- Every order is a box of 12 or 24. Mix any flavours inside it.
- Minimum 3 pieces of each flavour you pick.
- Add 3+ of any specialty and the whole box is specialty priced.
- Over 24 pieces? Send a DM and Shai will sort it out.
- Tax included — the price you see is the price you pay.
Pickup
Wednesdays, Tyndall
Pickup day — Wednesday
Cutoff — Sunday 7PM
Area — Tyndall, MB
Confirmed in 24–48 hrs
Biscoff
Caramelized speculoos baked right in.
Mini Eggs
Crunchy mini eggs in a soft, chewy cookie.
Matcha White Chocolate
Earthy matcha, creamy white chocolate chips.
Chocolate Chunk · Sea Salt
Gooey dark chocolate chunks, flaky sea salt.
Our story
Hi, I'm Shai
Sugar & Shai is my home-based cookie business, baking from scratch in small batches. Every cookie is thick, soft and properly loaded — and baked to order for your pickup day, never sitting on a shelf.
Whether you need a dozen for a birthday or a hundred for a wedding, I'm here to make your sweetest moments even sweeter.
Ready when you are
Reserve your cookies
Pick your flavours, choose a Wednesday, and Shai will confirm your spot within 24–48 hours.
Place an Order
