Handcrafted with Love
Sweet Cookies,
Beautiful Designs
Handcrafted cookies made from scratch in Tyndall, MB — pre-order pickup every Wednesday. Biscoff, Matcha, Chocolate Chunk & monthly specials.
Handcrafted cookies made from scratch in Tyndall, MB — pre-order pickup every Wednesday. Biscoff, Matcha, Chocolate Chunk & monthly specials.
Our Story
Hi, I'm Shai! Sugar & Shai is my home-based cookie business where baking meets artistry. Every cookie is hand-decorated with royal icing, made to order, and crafted with serious love and attention to detail.
Whether you need a dozen for a birthday or a hundred for a wedding — I'm here to make your sweetest moments even sweeter.
This Month
Our brand-new May limited edition — plus one last call on Ube Bliss before it disappears.
May 2026 Limited Edition
Flavour of the Month
citrusy, zesty and packed with real raspberry bits and white chocolate
Last Call
Encore
A little nutty, a little creamy, a whole lot of ube — made with real ube halaya and finished with toasted coconut + ube cream cheese filling.
Mother's Day Special
Limited Bundle · May Only
featuring 3 mini cookies + 6 cookies (one of each flavour to try!)
Add a Mom's BoxCurrent Menu
Flavours rotate seasonally — DM on Instagram to ask what's available right now!
That iconic caramelized speculoos flavour baked right into every bite.
Crunchy, chocolatey mini eggs folded into a soft, chewy cookie. A seasonal favourite.
Earthy matcha balanced with creamy white chocolate chips — elegant and delicious.
Gooey dark chocolate chunks finished with a sprinkle of flaky sea salt. Pure perfection.
Sweet Creations
A peek at our cookies — follow us on Instagram for more!
Happy Customers
"These cookies are INSANE. The biscoff ones didn't last a day in my house."
— Happy Customer
"Ordered for my daughter's birthday — everyone asked where the cookies were from!"
— Happy Customer
"Best cookies in Manitoba, hands down. The matcha white chocolate is next level."
— Happy Customer
The Process
Pre-orders only · Pickup in the Tyndall area · Minimum 3pc per flavour
Browse our flavours including the Flavour of the Month. Select quantities in multiples of 3 — minimum 3pc per flavour. Need more than 24 pieces? Slide into our DMs on Instagram!
Fill out the order form with your details, preferred pickup date, and payment method. Wednesdays are our regular pickup day — order cutoff is Sunday at 7PM the week before. Orders after cutoff are automatically moved to the following Wednesday.
Once your order is in, secure your spot with e-transfer or cash. Non-Wednesday pickups are subject to Shai's confirmation. Need it sooner? DM Shai on Instagram.
Shai will reach out on pickup day to coordinate a time. Pick up your freshly baked cookies in the Tyndall area and enjoy!
Place Your Order
Fill out the form below and Shai will get back to you to confirm your spot! Most orders confirmed within 24 hours.
Thanks for reaching out! Shai will confirm your spot within 24–48 hours.
Check your email for a reply.
Skip the Form
Not a form person? No worries — slide into our DMs or drop us an email and we'll get your order sorted just the same.
Home-based bakery · Pre-orders only · Pickup in Tyndall area · Please allow 24–48 hrs for a response